August 12, 2011
In its statement, Jais clarified that it was not a raid as reported. Nor was there any force used during the walkabout by Jais in the church’s premises. In its own words, it was just an “inspection”. Kinda like what Puspakon (sic) is doing on all vehicles which are sold second hand.
It could then be gathered from Jais’ statement that it was a friendly thingy. You know, the kind of visit by strangers to our house unannounced just after we have dinner with some guests where our guests were questioned why they were in our house; what did we, as hosts, say before, during and after dinner; did we, as hosts, try to proselytise (did I get the spelling correct? Sorry, I have to confirm this because before the raid, I never knew this word existed, let alone know its meaning) them yada yada yada.
Jais director Marzuki Hussin said, among others:
• Jais officers did not interrupt the event and only inspected the venue after the dinner had ended.
• Accusations that Jais raided, used force and trespassed are wild accusations.
• The 12 Muslims who had attended the event were only asked to provide their details and directed to attend counselling sessions.
I find this really amazing, really.
Our Honourable Prime Minister flew all the way to the Vatican to meet the Pope; shook his hand; gave the Pope a book and established a diplomatic relationship with the Vatican. Then he came back to Kuala Lumpur, cutting short his family holiday because he would rather be with us, the people.
And what did some little Caliphs, defenders of the faith do? Yes. Together with the police, they “inspected” a private dinner hosted, not by the church, but by an AIDS organisation to say thank you for all the hard work and efforts put into the organisation by some people.
The point is not whether it was a raid or inspection, Jais. Nor was it whether you entered before, during or after the dinner. Nor also whether there was any interruption. Nor whether you all were as nice as cupcakes.
That is NOT the point.
The point is you had the nerve to gate-crash a private dinner on the pretext of investigating a report the details of which you were unable to give when requested. And please tell me under what authority and for what reason the 12 Muslim guests were asked to attend counselling session with you?
What counselling? Counselling for what? For having dinner with some Christians? Judging from your rationale, the prime minister and his whole entourage to the Vatican might have to attend counselling to ya? Some time ago I attended a funeral of the son of a dear friend of mine in a church. I stood up when they were singing hymns and sat in silence when prayers were being said. Do I have to be counselled too?
This is the kind of thing which is making Malaysia a laughing capital of the world nowadays. Some years ago I remember, there was a text message sent out by none other than a mufti alleging that a number of kids were about to be proselytised (is my spelling correct?) at a church. It caused an uproar. But of course the good mufti was not hauled up for anything although recently a certain Penang woman was hauled up by the police for allegedly urging Christians to walk for whatever reason.
The thing which I would like to ask is this. Is there any necessity at all to do this kind of thing?
Muslims in Malaysia seem to be very weak indeed. We cannot listen to certain music groups. Cannot watch MTV. Cannot go to concerts, even to concerts by the completely fagotty Michael Learns to Rock, for God’s sake!!! These guys rhyme the word “car” with “star” for God’s sake! Cannot watch certain films. Cannot tahan seeing women’s ketiak in public. Cannot tahan seeing non-Muslims eating or drinking during puasa month.
We need to be protected all the time. Otherwise our aqidah would be gone. And we would become kafir. And of course we would then all go to hell.
A word of advice to Jais. We are a multi-cultural-faiths society. We need to be respectful of others. It doesn’t matter whether Islam is the official religion of the country or whether it is the faith of the majority of the people in our country.
Islam teaches us moderation. And Islam teaches us to be respectful of others.
Now, Article 11 of the Federal Constitution does guarantee freedom of religion to every person in Malaysia (even though that person is not a citizen of Malaysia). Admittedly, paragraph 4 of the said article also permits laws to be made to “control or restrict the propagation of any religious doctrine or belief among persons professing the religion of Islam.”
I do not know whether there is any such law in Selangor. But for argument’s sake, let’s assume that it has.
Nowhere in the law it is stated that Muslims cannot eat or attend a dinner with Christians, be it in a church compound or at the zoo or anywhere else. That is why even our Honourable Prime Minister attended a dinner with Christians some time ago (remember the hoo-haa about removing crucifixes and stuff?).
If there is reasonable suspicion (I repeat, reasonable suspicion — which means not any kind of grandmother suspicion) that some groups are trying to propagate whatever religious doctrine to Muslims, then by all means please take the appropriate action. Please note, I said, appropriate action, not any grandmother action.
Now what is appropriate and what is not? Well, again, we live in a multi-cultural-faiths society. Our actions must not be one which would or could give rise to disharmony. That is all.
By all means, Jais may investigate the allegation quietly. How to do that? Well, our Special Branch is one of the best in the world. Recently they even managed to sniff out a plot to wage war against the King; a plot to turn this country into a communist state; and they, according to the Deputy IGP and home minister, also managed to avoid a riot like the London riots in Kuala Lumpur. Yes. They are that good.
So Jais, how to investigate? Ask assistance from our Special Branch. They will know how to sniff this kinda thing within seconds.
When all or sufficient evidence is gathered of such activities, then Jais can go on and exercise its powers lah. Call people for statements. Arrest the people involved. Charge them in court. Habis cerita kan?
Better still, to be civilised, it would be better for Jais, in the name of 1 Malaysia, under those circumstances, to call up the church or group in question and confront them with the evidence which Jais has collected. Let’s hear what they have to say. If there is no reasonable or acceptable explanation, Jais can proceed to charge them.
That’s it. No drama. No raid. No inspection. Nothing at all.
Before I end this, one more point. Religion is a state matter. Selangor is governed by Pakatan Rakyat. I then presume Jais is a state agency. The mentri besar apparently did not agree with the action. Question — why wasn’t he briefed on the “inspection”, knowing how sensitive this issue is?
As a political party, PAS, which is part of Pakatan Rakyat, also apparently disagrees with Jais’ inspection. But Hasan Ali, a state exco member, defended Jais. The MB then imposed a blanket gag order.
May I ask bluntly, what the hell? Do you know what you are doing or not? If so, are you opposed or are you in favour of it? Which is bloody which?
If the MB doesn’t agree and one lone exco member is against that, what should be the natural consequence to that? My question is simple. What is the official position of the Selangor state government about this whole episode. Never mind Hasan Ali. Never mind Khalid. Never mind PAS or DAP.
WHAT IS THE OFFICIAL POSITION OF THE SELANGOR STATE GOVERNMENT?
That many of us would like to know.
No comments:
Post a Comment