There was no sign of sedition in Rev Eu
Hong Seng's Saturday remarks, all he did was to highlight important
issues concerning Article 153 of the federal constitution.
Advising the right wing group Perkasa to grow up, International Islamic University law professor Abdul Aziz Bari told Malaysiakini there should be space for differing opinions.
"I do not think Perkasa was right in making the police report. Though it is their right nonetheless police have better and more important things to do.
"I don't see any seditious tendency in the priest's remarks. In fact he has some important issues on Article 153.
"I think our society, especially right wing groups like Perkasa, should grow up and be willing to accord more space for difference of opinions.
"The most one can do is to ask the priest to explain his points," said the constitutional expert.
Abdul Aziz (left) said a 10-year study by Universiti Malaya students concluded that Malays were willing to share.
However, he said the only concern is issues like apostasy and even this at times has been blown up out of proportion.
"Is it because the priest is a non- Malay and non-Muslim, and therefore his remarks are considered seditious? We've to bear in mind that we are about to enter our 55th year of independence and yet we are still stuck in this mind-set in defending Article 153.
"The Reid commission recommended the provisions be reviewed by parliament 15 years after independence. Now after almost 55 years we are still talking about it," he pointed out.
On Saturday, Eu who is also the National Evangelical Christian Fellowship (NECF) chairperson touching on Article 153 said there is a need to talk on the rights of others and that it was bullying the minority.
Muhyiddin warns, Perkasa lodges report
Article 153 concerns the special privileges of the Malays and Bumiputera, guaranteed under the Constitution.
Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin had on Tuesday said it was incorrect to say the Article had a bullying effect on the minority.
Perkasa lodged a police report against Eu yesterday, wanting him investigated for sedition.
Abdul Aziz also referred to former premier Mahathir Mohamad, who in the mid 1990s looked down on the Malay reserve land, likening them to the Native American reservations in the US.
"There seems to be this tendency that Umno-Barisan Nasional can do whatever they want; just remember how Mahathir humiliated the rulers way back in 1983 and 1993.
"But somehow others cannot do that; as we will be accused of being derhaka (rebellious) and so on while Umno leaders are considered forward looking and so on," he said.
Advising the right wing group Perkasa to grow up, International Islamic University law professor Abdul Aziz Bari told Malaysiakini there should be space for differing opinions.
"I do not think Perkasa was right in making the police report. Though it is their right nonetheless police have better and more important things to do.
"I don't see any seditious tendency in the priest's remarks. In fact he has some important issues on Article 153.
"I think our society, especially right wing groups like Perkasa, should grow up and be willing to accord more space for difference of opinions.
"The most one can do is to ask the priest to explain his points," said the constitutional expert.
Abdul Aziz (left) said a 10-year study by Universiti Malaya students concluded that Malays were willing to share.However, he said the only concern is issues like apostasy and even this at times has been blown up out of proportion.
"Is it because the priest is a non- Malay and non-Muslim, and therefore his remarks are considered seditious? We've to bear in mind that we are about to enter our 55th year of independence and yet we are still stuck in this mind-set in defending Article 153.
"The Reid commission recommended the provisions be reviewed by parliament 15 years after independence. Now after almost 55 years we are still talking about it," he pointed out.
On Saturday, Eu who is also the National Evangelical Christian Fellowship (NECF) chairperson touching on Article 153 said there is a need to talk on the rights of others and that it was bullying the minority.
Muhyiddin warns, Perkasa lodges report
Article 153 concerns the special privileges of the Malays and Bumiputera, guaranteed under the Constitution.
Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin had on Tuesday said it was incorrect to say the Article had a bullying effect on the minority.
Perkasa lodged a police report against Eu yesterday, wanting him investigated for sedition.
Abdul Aziz also referred to former premier Mahathir Mohamad, who in the mid 1990s looked down on the Malay reserve land, likening them to the Native American reservations in the US.
"There seems to be this tendency that Umno-Barisan Nasional can do whatever they want; just remember how Mahathir humiliated the rulers way back in 1983 and 1993.
"But somehow others cannot do that; as we will be accused of being derhaka (rebellious) and so on while Umno leaders are considered forward looking and so on," he said.
martin luther king would have preached otherwise....plz listen to his sermon ...love your enemies...certaintly rev eu has forgoten the directive of our Lord and Savior...the AGAPE LOVE....or maybe perhaps it is easy to preach than practice....Sometimes i wonder why Jesus calls certain people brood of vipers....
ReplyDelete